Monday, September 5, 2011

The Question of Why

The Question of Why

Yesterday I learned that a friend of mine passed away. Amy was only 32 years old and had her whole life ahead of her. Cancer, a stem cell transplant, and a weakened immune system kept her from fighting a bacterial infection. She fought so hard and had come through so much, everyone was sure she would win this battle as well. Sadly, the infection was stronger than her body. She left parents, a sister and many, many loving friends who stood vigilantly by her side. Day by day. Hour by hour. Minute by minute. Second by second. Until the Lord, our Redeemer took her home. For Amy there is true victory. She is at the place we all hope to call our home, but for her family and friends there is a longing, a heartache, memories to cherish, and other memories they wish they never had. There is pain, fear, and grief that will linger for years and years to come. And I don’t write that flippantly, I know emotional pain, and I know grief. After the sorrow, after something so painful strikes so remorselessly…a question lingers. Why?
I remember when I was in admitted to the hospital for four consecutive days of chemotherapy, the why question ran through my thoughts over and over again. It wasn’t the “why me God” question. I really didn’t feel sorry for myself. I knew to pray and believe that God would heal me, but I also knew of some dear friends who loved the Lord who died from their disease. How could I say God would heal me, when He didn’t heal others? Why does He seem to let some people live their lives in fullness, while the lives of others are cut short? As I wrestled with those questions, I came to the realization that each of our lives are unique and God’s plans for each of us are unique and it was wrong to compare the workings of God in my life with the life of another person. It is a matter of trust in God’s individual sovereign plan.
After Amy died, those questions surfaced again in my psyche. Why would someone so young leave this life, while others remain? As I cancer survivor myself, with multiple surgeries and treatments, there were plenty of times my own life could have been “cut short”, yet I’ve continued my life. Someone recently said I was “highly favored of the Lord.” That may be, but how could God love someone more than another person when Christ died for all of us? It’s not a matter of God’s love. It’s a matter of God’s plan. Recently I was reading a book “ The Horse and His Boy” in the Chronicles of Narnia by C.S. Lewis. I know C.S. Lewis wasn’t considered a prophet, but in his writings (even in children’s’ stories) he shares some spiritual insight that hit home with me. The story is an adventure about a boy and a girl each with a horse running away to the land of Narnia, where they would be free. Along the journey of frightening images and characters, they meet the mysterious, magnificent lion named Aslan. He is the ruler of Narnia and in the book represents Jesus, the Lion of Judah. Several things happen that the children do not understand. There were times that they didn’t understand the things Aslan did; things that seemed cruel at the time, but in the long-term worked for their good. For example, Aslan scratched the back of the girl with His claws, so she would “feel” the way she mistreated another character. The child questions Aslan.
“Then it was You that wounded Aravis?”
“It was I“.”
“But what for?”
“Child,” said the Voice, “I am telling you your story, not hers. I tell no- one any story but his own.”
I am also reminded of the gospel of John in the last chapter when Jesus asked Peter three times if he (Peter) loved Him. Each time Jesus told Peter to feed and tend to his sheep. He also had some sobering words for the apostle..

Most assuredly, I say to you when you were younger, you girded yourself and walked where you wished; but when you are old you will stretch out your hands, and another will gird you and carry you where you do not wish.” (John 21:18) few verses later he told Peter “Follow me.”

The disciple John was close by. Peter turned and asked Jesus “What about him?” Jesus gave Peter direction, but not the disciple John. Peter was probably asking “Why are you telling me to “feed your sheep” and “follow you” and yet you haven’t said a thing to John. I think Peter was saying to himself, “What about John? What do want John to do? Why haven’t you told John to “feed your sheep? What is your plan for John?” Jesus’ response almost seems aloof. “If I will that he remain till I come, what is that to you? You follow me.”
In other words, Jesus was telling Peter” I ’m telling you about your story and your life“. John’s life was basically none of Peter’s business. Likewise Aslan tells the child in “The Horse and His Boy” He tells no-one a story but their own, and what he does in another’s persons life is between He and that individual. His call or commission is unique to that person’s life story.
While this doesn’t answer the question why, it certainly provides some room for thought and helps us let go of what we don’t and can’t possibly understand, and trust that God knows what He’s doing and doesn’t want us to belabor and bemoan what we can’t fathom.
I don’t know why Amy is no longer here with us, and I don’t understand why Nancy is not here planning her next trip to El Salvador, or why I’m not going out to lunch with Olivia. I loved to watch her put ketchup on her spaghetti because it was also made from tomatoes (she was far from Italian). But I am coming to understand that He doesn’t want me compare my life to anyone else’s. and neither should you. He tells no-one any story but his own.
Thank you Lord that You hold all of my days in the palm of Your tender hands. Thank you Lord that you are “the Father of compassion, and the God of all comfort who comforts us in our troubles.” Amen (2 Corinthians 1:3)